This Is My Truth 2018 Boxset and tour(?) - Page 12 - Forever Delayed

LA ex · #**166** 17-09-2018, 19:35

Whilst Prologue should have been on the album originally, there's at least six songs I'd replace before Nobody Loved You.

Theory: Nicky has in the past said that they won't perform NLY live anymore because it's too emotional for him. If they are playing the album live and in full have they decided to change the track listing so that they don't have to play it?

Phil C · #**167** 17-09-2018, 20:01

Quote:

Originally Posted by LA ex

Whilst Prologue should have been on the album originally, there's at least six songs I'd replace before Nobody Loved You.

Theory: Nicky has in the past said that they won't perform NLY live anymore because it's too emotional for him. If they are playing the album live and in full have they decided to change the track listing so that they don't have to play it?

I'd not heard Nick say that. Would be odd given that the band have been happy to play Cardiff Afterlife, As Holy As The Soil and Walk Me To The Bridge.

Mr Richey · #**168** 17-09-2018, 20:18

I don’t agree with this new trend where the lads re-release an album and change the tracklisting...

...but if I was going to junk anything from TIMTTMY, it would be “You Stole The Sun From My Heart” without a second’s hesitation.

everlasting · #**169** 17-09-2018, 20:42

Well, that's a load of old bollocks. WHy chop off a song that they were going to release as their lead single initially and then never gave it any love at all? Well, this sums up their dislike for the song clearly, swapping it for a b-side? I thought it was daft when they did it with the SATT 10th anniversary. Better be some good stuff on the 2nd disc and a jam-packed DVD or I'll sadly pass on this until it's like £3 somewhere in a few months.

Porco · #**170** 17-09-2018, 20:52

Easily fixed though.

Routine Builder · #**171** 17-09-2018, 20:59

Wouldn't it been better if Prologue was placed after SYMM? There's something about the title that makes me think it should be payed after the album rather than inserted into it...

Phil C · #**172** 17-09-2018, 22:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Routine Builder

Wouldn't it been better if Prologue was placed after SYMM? There's something about the title that makes me think it should be payed after the album rather than inserted into it...

Before it, surely?

Phil C · #**173** 17-09-2018, 22:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by Porco

Easily fixed though.

Not if you're listening to it on vinyl.

Phil C · #**174** 17-09-2018, 22:09

Quote:

Originally Posted by everlasting

Well, that's a load of old bollocks. WHy chop off a song that they were going to release as their lead single initially and then never gave it any love at all? Well, this sums up their dislike for the song clearly, swapping it for a b-side? I thought it was daft when they did it with the SATT 10th anniversary. Better be some good stuff on the 2nd disc and a jam-packed DVD or I'll sadly pass on this until it's like £3 somewhere in a few months.

I've never heard that NLY was supposed to be the lead single before.

I do find it bizarre that people are saying they'll not buy the re-issue because of this - surely NLY, as good as it is, isn't the main reason for buying a box-set?

Porco · #**175** 18-09-2018, 01:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phil C

Not if you're listening to it on vinyl.

Ok, but if you’re listening on vinyl you’re going to have to get involved manually at some point anyway...

Marconi Delorian · #**176** 18-09-2018, 08:50

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phil C

I've never heard that NLY was supposed to be the lead single before.

I do find it bizarre that people are saying they'll not buy the re-issue because of this - surely NLY, as good as it is, isn't the main reason for buying a box-set?

It wasn't, must be thinking of Be Natural.