Umbrella: Yay, ay, ay ay or Nay, ay, ay, ay?

[A boy called Rita]

Well, it had to come eventually!

Manic Street Preachers cover Umbrella...

[nogeneration]

a big fat yay from me...

[Always/Never]

Huge yay from me too

[Son of Stopped]

Was hoping a poll would pop up. I voted Yay. People take themselves far too seriously these days...

[everlasting]

I wouldn't give it either, personally. More of something in the middle, but I've voted yay.

[Joe-eh]

A HUGE yay from me.
It's a great cover of what i think is one of the best pop songs, atleast from 2007.

Nay.

[Alexkid]

Yay from me as well

Was slightly dubious about it before I heard it, but now I love it. It could only be improved my getting GLC to do the rap bit

[hummingbird]

YAAAAAAAAAAY

[klaps1987]

I LOVE THEEEEEEEEEEMMMMMMMM.Man they're crazy!!!!

[A boy called Rita]

Originally Posted by klaps1987

I LOVE THEEEEEEEEEEMMMMMMMM.Man they're crazy!!!!

But you voted you don't like it?

[BordersPaul]

It gets the thumbs up for me.

[Amanda]

Originally Posted by Alexkid

It could only be improved my getting GLC to do the rap bit

Are you dissin the plan to get Wire to do it? He's straight outta the 'Port too, has a hoodie, trousers that look like a shellsuit, what more creditionals does a man need?

And yay for now, not sure how it will stand up to many many repeated plays or whether I'll be listenning to it for years to come but for what it is it does it well, and makes me smile.

[Alexkid]

Originally Posted by Amanda

Are you dissin the plan to get Wire to do it? He's straight outta the 'Port too, has a hoodie, trousers that look like a shellsuit, what more creditionals does a man need?

Don't disrespect me beeyatch The only way it can be decided is for Wire and GLC to settle it over a dance-off at the NME gig.

[klaps1987]

The fact is that, when I voted I thought that the whole thread was another one of those science-fiction ideas, but then I realised it was a fact so when I heard it ,I loved it.As far as I know I can't change my vote now...