Journal for Plague Lovers

[newtransistorhero]

Journal for Plague Lovers

I remember getting this album and thinking it was good. It took a little while to get into it. After that little while I just can't stop. This album is brilliant. Everything about it is just wonderful.

Lyrically, it's from 1995. In the MSP canon, it's between The Holy Bible, and Everything Must Go. Now, they are two of my most favourite albums, and I always searched for a link between the two. I always thought it was "This is Yesterday”, a track from The Holy Bible with a wonderful, inspiring solo, totally MSP lyric, but different enough to point to a potentially new direction.

Now I realise that this album was to be the link.

However, that's not to say that I'm not glad we had to wait for it. I honestly don't think that this album would have been this good, or even sound anything like it does, if it had been released in 1995 (when it logically should have been). If you think about it, if Richey hadn't disappeared, we would have probably never had Everything Must Go, we wouldn't have had A Design for Life, or Interiors, or No Surface, All Feeling. I think that the Manics had to record that album, and then go through the subsequent albums, (This is my Truth Tell Me Yours, Know Your Enemy, Lifeblood, Send Away the Tigers), if only for James Dean Bradfield to develop the musical ability to write music for such a record.

On the face of it, it was an daft idea. Take lyrics from your former (now presumed dead) lyricist and make a new record. In many ways, the Manics had become a bit of an irrelevance by 2009, I mean, there were a few of us, buying the albums and getting excited when a new one came out. Always giving the benefit of the doubt (with the exception of lifeblood, a fucking awful record) to Nicky Wire even though it was blindingly obvious that he couldn't carry a record on his own. Over 4 albums, there were maybe 2 albums worth of good songs, if that. So Nicky took the folder, sorted the words into songs, and created another masterpiece.

Journal for Plague Lovers carries itself with the cream of Manics Albums, and also carries itself with the cream of albums in general

It's starts brilliantly, really violently, the Bass and Guitar combine to make a sound not heard on Manics albums for years. The first line, “The more I see, the less I scream” Totally MSP. The verse gives way to a chorus straight out of EMG, but with these lyrics full of reference, which you don't quite understand until you look into it, you know, like a Manics album should be. No whining about “oh i'm on tour and everyone loves me but I can't take it” or “American is taking over the world, so i'd better complain, why isn't communism winning” or really bad jokes on a Beach Boys pastiche. No, lyrics that make you listen closer and think.

It gives way to a song which echoes one of their first influences. I hate Guns 'n' Roses, but I understand the influence, and I can hear it in Jackie Collins. It sounds like a single, until JDB delivers that line, “If a married man FUCKS a catholic” It's with such venom, such power. The song is upbeat, radio friendly if you will, and in true Manic Street Preachers style, the mass communication is inverted. Next is the song that really got me when I first heard it. The riff is sensational, huge and powerful, then the stop. MSP lyrics with a brilliant chorus, the 100,000 in the Bombay fight is a random reference, to the huge crowds Giant Haystacks (The Loch Ness Monster in WCW – RIP Martin Raune) used to pull against Big Daddy, or Hulk Hogan. This Joke Sport Severed slows things down before a classic of the MSP canon, Journal for Plague Lovers. “Only a God can bruise, Only a God can soothe, only a God reserves the right, to forgive those who revile him” beautiful lyric. Very Richey, very MSP. Something I don't think Nicky could have written.

She bathed herself... this kind of reminds me of Watsville blues, which is actually a Nicky Wire song (Nicky plays guitar and sings on Watsville blues) great chorus again though, moves on from the verse in a in a huge celebration before getting back to a snarling verse with slightly discordant guitar, giving way to a song which is beautiful on the demo. The refrain, totally Richey, “This beauty here, dipping neophobia” It's like these three tracks were needed to recover from the onslaught of the first part of the album. In a way, you think the album is going to sink into a bit of soft rock, but no. Marlon J.D. kicks in. I believe that Richey really went for Marlon Brando as a hero. “I will not beg because, that is not who I am” is a line that I think Richey associated with Brando and also himself. He then goes through crucifixion, and a song about the self loathing and alienation that he felt and I can relate to, (It feels like I'm speaking a foreign language sometimes), the ramblings which extreme depression can bring (which I believe is the reason that Nicky included Pretension/Repulsion on the record) before getting to a massively MSP topic. A song about the compulsory sterilisation of the unfit (I mean, what else?) Virginia State Epileptic Colony is possible the most Manicsy song written since 1998. An amazing lyric with a fantastic tune and slightly desolate sound. It gives way to possibly the only brilliant Nicky Wire led song, William's Last Words. Nicky said this song was very difficult, and it is in fact, the only 100% Nicky composition (obviously, with the Richey lyrics, but you know what I mean) on the record. His vocal is truly amazing, a man with a bloody awful voice, who's never really been able to write a song, wrote that... I actually compare it to The Sound of Silence by Simon and Garfunkel. I think it carries that much with it, (although it took Paul Simon 4 songs to write something that beautiful. It took Nicky Wire 8 studio albums and one solo album, but that doesn't really matter I suppose). I think William's last words is a suicide note. Others disagree, but I do

Then the hidden track

I AM NOT DEAD

Beautifully done,

A triumph. A classic. A win. The essence of FTW.

An album worth listening to. An album I genuinely hope will be remembered as a classic. I get the feeling that it will be one of those Rock Snob albums, you know, only recognised about 20 years later for how brilliant is Itactually is.

It confirmed my belief that this band are still one of the most important artists of our time,

I used to think to myself, that my children (when they are born, and old enough) would ask me about the Manic Street Preachers. I thought that I would say that there was a time when the Manic Street Preachers were the most important band in the world.

My child would say, “but Dad, they recorded Lifeblood”

I would have to say, “well yes, yes they did, but 15 years apart, they recorded 2 of the greatest albums ever put to posterity, as well as Generation Terrorists, a massive statement of intent and decadence, and Everything Must Go. One of the single greatest albums ever recorded.

I just wonder though, if they had this up their sleeve, what the hell have they been doing since,1998

[Heart2Heart]

Well there's nothing really wrong with Lifeblood. I don't get the intense love or intense hate it gets.

JFPL is my favourite Manics album, probably my favourite music album, so can't disagree with the rest of your stuff.

[a story on the radio]

thanks for taking the time to write that newtransistorhero, i enjoyed reading it. one thing though. i don't think all of the lyrics were left post holy bible. i think it was just stuff that he'd had lying around for ages. let's be fair, even on the printed lyrics none of them made much sense.

you should send that to REPEAT. it's a great piece of writing.

[Bobafettish]

After reading Lipstick Traces, by Greil Marcus, about dadaists, situationists and punks, JFPL's nonsense now makes sense

[Heart2Heart]

Originally Posted by Bobafettish

After reading Lipstick Traces, by Greil Marcus, about dadaists, situationists and punks, JFPL's nonsense now makes sense

I dream of a fan-annotated JFPL one day.

[newtransistorhero]

Originally Posted by a story on the radio

thanks for taking the time to write that newtransistorhero, i enjoyed reading it. one thing though. i don't think all of the lyrics were left post holy bible. i think it was just stuff that he'd had lying around for ages. let's be fair, even on the printed lyrics none of them made much sense.

you should send that to REPEAT. it's a great piece of writing.

I think you're right about the lyrics. He was writing them before THB and afterwards. Were there about 30 songs/poems/Hikaus? They didn't make a lot of sense and Nicky did do a great job putting them together. I guess I meant that the lyrics would have been considered on the record after The Holy Bible. I think it's wierd how fate works.

Thanks for the compliment,

[andy]

Originally Posted by newtransistorhero

I think you're right about the lyrics. He was writing them before THB and afterwards. Were there about 30 songs/poems/Hikaus? They didn't make a lot of sense and Nicky did do a great job putting them together. I guess I meant that the lyrics would have been considered on the record after The Holy Bible. I think it's wierd how fate works.

Thanks for the compliment,

There was considerations from various sources I have read where Nicky said he considered the idea of putting the infamous ring binder out as a book - It would have been interesting to have seen the folder as a whole from the various cuttings, clippings, paintings etc not to mention the lyrics themselves.

Nicky said a lot was one or two lines and a lot was disjointed but it would have been interesting to see the folder as it was left unedited. Although there are aparantly some very macabre lines in there.

Overall people say JFPL has an air of acceptance about it where James (I think it was) said something along the lines that compared to the bible Journal is the work of someone who has stopped asking questions and decided what the answers are and where he is. Its debatable how much of that is due to wire's editing process on certain tracks and how much is Richey's mindset at the time?

[Europa Gluten Free]

Even if Richey hadn't decided to disappear in 1995 I'd say he would have left the band anyway. The other 3 were pulling in a different direction. They wanted piece of the Britpop or post-Britpop pie.

[a story on the radio]

Originally Posted by proevpete

Even if Richey hadn't decided to disappear in 1995 I'd say he would have left the band anyway. The other 3 were pulling in a different direction. They wanted piece of the Britpop or post-Britpop pie.

that's true. i recall a richey quote about the next album as something like "nine inch nails meet pantera".

[Flint]

Originally Posted by newtransistorhero

what the hell have they been doing since,1998

Turning from a great band to an amazing one, pretty much.

[jack_duckworth]

interesting post.
all very pro-richey and somewhat negative to the band they became without him though, especially the digs at nicky.
plus a double lifeblood bash *eek*, that never goes down well 'round 'ere

[newtransistorhero]

Originally Posted by jack_duckworth

interesting post.
all very pro-richey and somewhat negative to the band they became without him though, especially the digs at nicky.
plus a double lifeblood bash *eek*, that never goes down well 'round 'ere

I am quite pro Richey. I think the Manics are so much more when there are four of them. I'm not saying they wrote nothing of note after EMG because they did. I don't think they recorded another brilliant record though. (until Journal) Every album had it's fair share of rubbish on it and could have been trimmed down.

I really don't like Lifeblood though. I've never been more disappointed by a record that i've looked forward to. I hated everything about it. However, i remember reading an interview with Nicky where he said that Lifeblood was THB for 35 year olds, so in 5 years and 3 months, i'm going to try it again. I haven't listened to it since about 3 weeks after it was released.

[meganslastwords]

Very good piece of writing, agree with a lot of it as JFPL is my second favourite Manics album, not so keen on the Nicky's lyrics / Lifeblood bashing but everyone has different opinions

[a story on the radio]

for me they are the only band that i really love. them and therapy?. that's why i am only on two band forums. this and therapy?'s forum are the only nice ones. and it's a grammatical nightmare to do therapy? ever.

[Europa Gluten Free]

If this is a great piece of writing then REPEAT must be some publication.