The "You can't please everyone" thread...

[Ben]

So, it seems there is a lot of mixed feeling about PFAYM and the Manics in general on here at the moment. I thought I'd start a thread for all the people who are disappointed with the current state of the band (for whatever reason). I'm interested to know what you would have liked them to have done differently at this point to make you happy? I'm after serious suggestions, and constructive criticism, so no "They shld play a gig in my front roomz, LOLZ!!!1!one!" or "They're shit!!1!! ROFL" comments if at all possible, please.

If you don't like PFAYM, for instance, why is that? And what would you have liked them to have recorded instead? Another Lifeblood style album? The Holy Bible Pt. 2? etc.

What would hold or win back your interest? Go!