Rate RIF songs.

[Leec]

First post so hope you're all gentle Here's my list but as many of you have said it keeps changing:

1. In Eternity
2. Broken Algorithms
3. People Give In
4. Distant Colours
5. Sequels of Forgotten Wars
6. International Blue
7. Dylan & Caitlin
8. Song for the Sadness
9. Hold Me Like a Heaven
10. Liverpool Revisited
11. Vivian
12. The Left Behind

[cameron33]

Hold me like a Heaven 9/10
People Give In 8.5/10
International Blue 8/10
A Song for the Sadness 7.5/10
Distant Colours 7/10
In Eternity 7/10
Liverpool Revisited 6.5/10
Dylan & Caitlin 6.5/10
Sequels of Forgotten Wars 6/10
Broken Algorithms 6/10
Vivian 6/10
The Left Behind 4/10

[mr_muse_man]

35 lists compiled

1. International Blue - 135
2. People Give In - 153
3. Hold Me Like A Heaven - 169
4. In Eternity - 183
5. Sequels of Forgotten Wars - 193
6. Song for the Sadness - 219
7. Distant Colours - 237
8. Liverpool Revisited - 254
9. Broken Algorithms - 269
10. Dylan & Caitlin - 279
11. Vivan - 304
12. The Left Behind - 341

[Frozendiva]

Originally Posted by mr_muse_man

35 lists compiled

1. International Blue - 135
2. People Give In - 153
3. Hold Me Like A Heaven - 169
4. In Eternity - 183
5. Sequels of Forgotten Wars - 193
6. Song for the Sadness - 219
7. Distant Colours - 237
8. Liverpool Revisited - 254
9. Broken Algorithms - 269
10. Dylan & Caitlin - 279
11. Vivan - 304
12. The Left Behind - 341

Your scale runs best to worst with the lowest score being the highest grade?

[mr_muse_man]

Originally Posted by Frozendiva

Your scale runs best to worst with the lowest score being the highest grade?

Yes. So for example, if everyone so far (35 lists) had voted International Blue their #1 favourite track it would have a score of 35

[Frozendiva]

Originally Posted by mr_muse_man

Yes. So for example, if everyone so far (35 lists) had voted International Blue their #1 favourite track it would have a score of 35

It was Sunday night and I was tired and thought you had made 35 lists of your own, hence my puzzlement.

[darkanddivine]

1. Sequels of Forgotten Wars
2. People Give In
3. In Eternity
4. International Blue
5. Hold Me Like a Heaven
6. Song for the Sadness
7. Vivian
8. The Left Behind
9. Distant Colours
10. Dylan & Caitlin
11. Liverpool Revisited
12. Broken Algorithms

[Fabulous Disaster]

1. International Blue
2. Hold Me Like A Heaven
3. Liverpool Revisited
4. A Song For The Sadness
5. In Eternity
6. Sequels Of Forgotten Wars
7. Distant Colours
8. Broken Algorithms
9. People Give In
10. Dylan and Caitlin
11. Vivian
12. The Left Behind

[darkanddivine]

Originally Posted by mr_muse_man

35 lists compiled

1. International Blue - 135
2. People Give In - 153
3. Hold Me Like A Heaven - 169
4. In Eternity - 183
5. Sequels of Forgotten Wars - 193
6. Song for the Sadness - 219
7. Distant Colours - 237
8. Liverpool Revisited - 254
9. Broken Algorithms - 269
10. Dylan & Caitlin - 279
11. Vivan - 304
12. The Left Behind - 341

I (mostly) agree with the forum groupthink.

[tomd2103]

Had a few weeks of listening now and had a bit of a change of mind. I initially would have omitted Vivian and The Left Behind off the album (I don't mind the latter but it feels a bit tacked on after what feels like the last song just as Mayakovsky, William's Last Words and SYMM were on previous albums), but Vivian has grown on me even though it is a bit weak lyrically and the chorus is a bit repetitive.

I initially liked Dylan and Caitlin and like the concept and the lyrics of the song, but am feeling more and more that it doesn't really fit with the rest of the album.